Commercial real estate partnerships can provide an efficient way for investors, developers, operators, and property owners to combine capital and expertise. The same structure can become difficult when the partners disagree about financing, distributions, management authority, capital contributions, property sales, refinancing, leasing, development decisions, or the future of the investment. Because the real estate may continue generating income and carrying debt while the dispute proceeds, partnership litigation often requires attention to both legal rights and ongoing property operations.
California partnership disputes can involve breach of the partnership agreement, fiduciary duties, access to financial records, unauthorized transactions, accounting claims, partner dissociation, buyout rights, judicial expulsion, and dissolution. The available remedy depends heavily on how the ownership arrangement was structured. Property owned by a partnership is legally different from property owned directly by individuals as tenants in common, and a partner’s economic interest in a partnership should not automatically be treated as a direct fractional ownership interest in the real estate itself.
The Ownership Structure Should Be Identified First
Before evaluating remedies, the parties should determine exactly how the commercial property is owned.
Real estate may be held through:
- A general partnership;
- A limited partnership;
- A limited liability company;
- A corporation;
- A joint venture;
- A tenancy in common;
- A trust;
- Several affiliated entities; or
- A combination of ownership structures.
The legal remedies available to an LLC member, general partner, limited partner, shareholder, or direct co-owner can differ substantially.
A business relationship may be informally described as a “partnership” even though the governing documents establish a different entity. Litigation should begin with the actual legal structure rather than the terminology used casually by the owners.
The Partnership Agreement Usually Controls the Owners’ Relationship
California’s Uniform Partnership Act generally permits the partnership agreement to govern relations among the partners and between the partners and partnership, subject to statutory limitations.
A commercial property partnership agreement may address:
- Ownership percentages;
- Initial capital contributions;
- Future capital calls;
- Management authority;
- Voting requirements;
- Property acquisitions;
- Borrowing;
- Refinancing;
- Leasing;
- Property management;
- Construction and development;
- Distributions;
- Partner compensation;
- Transfers of partnership interests;
- Dissociation;
- Buyout rights;
- Death or disability;
- Dissolution;
- Valuation procedures; and
- Dispute resolution.
If the partnership agreement does not address an issue, California statutory default rules may become important.
Some Statutory Partnership Rights Cannot Simply Be Eliminated
Although partnership agreements can alter many default rules, California law limits the extent to which partners may waive certain statutory protections.
For example, a partnership agreement generally cannot unreasonably restrict statutory access to partnership books and records. California law also limits the extent to which an agreement can eliminate fiduciary duties of loyalty and care or the obligation of good faith and fair dealing.
This can become important when a controlling partner argues that broad contractual discretion eliminates all accountability to the other owners.
The agreement must be interpreted together with statutory restrictions on contractual modification.
Partnership Property Belongs to the Partnership
California Corporations Code Section 16203 provides that property acquired by a partnership belongs to the partnership rather than to the partners individually.
This distinction is particularly important in commercial real estate litigation.
If a partnership owns an office building, shopping center, industrial property, or development parcel, an individual partner generally cannot treat part of the real estate as that partner’s personally owned parcel simply because the partner owns a percentage of the partnership.
The partnership owns the property. The partners possess rights arising from their partnership interests.
How the Property Was Acquired Can Determine Whether It Is Partnership Property
California Corporations Code Section 16204 contains rules for determining whether property belongs to the partnership.
Property is generally partnership property when it is acquired:
- In the partnership’s name;
- In the name of partners acting in their capacity as partners under qualifying documentation; or
- Using partnership assets, which can create a statutory presumption of partnership ownership.
By contrast, property acquired in one or more partners’ individual names without reference to the partnership and without use of partnership assets may be presumed to be separate property even if the partnership later uses it.
Disputes involving older commercial properties may therefore require review of deeds, purchase funds, partnership records, tax documents, loan records, and the parties’ original understanding.
A Partner Is Not a Direct Co-Owner of Partnership Real Estate
California Corporations Code Section 16501 expressly provides that a partner is not a co-owner of partnership property and does not possess an individually transferable interest in specific partnership property.
The partner’s transferable partnership interest is generally the partner’s share of partnership profits and losses and right to receive distributions, which California law treats as personal property.
This distinction affects several common disputes involving:
- Attempted transfers of partnership real estate;
- Partition claims;
- Partner creditor claims;
- Buyouts;
- Divorce or estate issues;
- Dissociation;
- Foreclosure on partner interests; and
- Dissolution.
Partition Is Not Automatically Available When the Partnership Owns the Property
Owners sometimes assume that a partner can file a partition action and force sale of partnership-owned commercial real estate.
That assumption can be incorrect.
Because a partner is not individually a co-owner of partnership property, the partner ordinarily does not hold the same direct property interest as a tenant in common who owns an undivided interest in real estate.
If the real estate is owned by the partnership, partnership remedies such as enforcement of the partnership agreement, dissociation, buyout, dissolution, or winding up may be more relevant.
If the individuals instead own the property directly as tenants in common, partition remedies may require separate analysis.
Management Authority Is a Frequent Source of Partnership Litigation
Commercial property partnerships frequently divide management responsibility among the partners.
One partner may be responsible for daily operations while major decisions require approval from multiple owners.
Potential disputed decisions include:
- Signing leases;
- Replacing tenants;
- Hiring property managers;
- Approving repairs;
- Obtaining loans;
- Refinancing existing debt;
- Entering construction contracts;
- Approving redevelopment;
- Selling the property;
- Making distributions;
- Entering affiliate transactions; and
- Settling significant litigation.
The partnership agreement should be reviewed to determine whether the disputed act required unilateral management authority, majority approval, unanimous consent, or another voting threshold.
California Has Default Rules When the Partnership Agreement Is Silent
Under California Corporations Code Section 16401, each partner generally has equal rights in the management and conduct of the partnership business unless the partnership agreement provides otherwise.
The statute also generally permits differences concerning ordinary-course partnership business to be decided by a majority of the partners.
Acts outside the ordinary course of the partnership business generally require consent of all partners under the statutory default rule.
This distinction can become central in disputes involving major commercial real estate decisions.
A Property Sale May Be Outside Ordinary Business
Whether a sale of commercial real estate falls within the partnership’s ordinary business depends on the nature and purpose of the partnership.
For a partnership created to buy and resell development property, sales may be part of ordinary operations.
For a partnership formed solely to hold one income-producing building for long-term investment, sale of the partnership’s primary asset may present a substantially different issue.
Relevant evidence can include:
- The partnership agreement;
- The stated purpose of the partnership;
- Prior property transactions;
- The investment plan;
- Communications among partners;
- Loan documents; and
- Historical business practices.
Partners Can Bind the Partnership in Dealings With Third Parties
California Corporations Code Section 16301 generally provides that each partner acts as an agent of the partnership for purposes of partnership business.
An act apparently carrying on the partnership’s business in the ordinary course can bind the partnership unless the partner lacked authority and the third party knew or had notice of that lack of authority.
An act outside the ordinary course generally binds the partnership only if authorized by the other partners.
This can create difficult disputes when one partner signs:
- A lease;
- A property management agreement;
- A construction contract;
- A loan document;
- An easement;
- A purchase contract;
- A settlement agreement; or
- Another significant instrument without required internal approval.
Internal Lack of Authority Does Not Always Resolve Third-Party Rights
A partner may breach the partnership agreement by entering a transaction without required internal approval, yet the transaction may still create obligations involving an innocent third party depending on apparent authority and applicable law.
This creates two different questions:
- Was the partnership bound to the third party?
- Did the partner breach duties owed internally to the partnership or other partners?
The answers are not necessarily identical.
Statements of Partnership Authority Can Affect Real Estate Transactions
California partnership law permits filing of statements addressing a partner’s authority in specified circumstances.
These documents can become particularly important with real estate because third parties, title companies, lenders, and buyers may need confirmation concerning who possesses authority to transfer or encumber partnership property.
Commercial partnerships should maintain clear documentation concerning authority to:
- Sell real estate;
- Execute deeds;
- Grant easements;
- Execute deeds of trust;
- Refinance;
- Sign major leases; and
- Enter other material property transactions.
Unauthorized Refinancing Can Create Significant Internal Claims
One partner may obtain or modify financing without the approval required by the partnership agreement.
The consequences can be substantial because new financing may:
- Increase leverage;
- Change interest rates;
- Extend loan maturity;
- Create prepayment penalties;
- Require additional guaranties;
- Restrict distributions;
- Impose cash management controls;
- Encumber additional assets; or
- Increase foreclosure risk.
The other partners may seek remedies for breach of the partnership agreement or fiduciary duties even when the lender’s rights must be analyzed separately.
Capital Contribution Disputes Can Threaten Commercial Property
Commercial real estate frequently requires additional capital after acquisition.
Funds may be needed for:
- Debt service;
- Tenant improvements;
- Major repairs;
- Construction;
- Insurance;
- Property taxes;
- Environmental remediation;
- Leasing costs;
- Operating deficits;
- Loan paydowns; and
- Emergency expenditures.
The partners may disagree about whether additional capital is required and whether a partner can be compelled to contribute it.
A Partner’s Additional Funding Obligation Depends on the Agreement
Partners should not assume that every owner is automatically required to contribute unlimited additional money whenever the property needs cash.
The partnership agreement may establish:
- Mandatory capital calls;
- Optional contributions;
- Contribution percentages;
- Maximum funding amounts;
- Emergency funding procedures;
- Member or partner loans;
- Default interest;
- Dilution;
- Loss of voting rights; or
- Other remedies for failure to fund.
Before imposing a default remedy, the partnership should determine whether the capital call was actually authorized and issued according to the agreement.
Improper Capital Calls Can Be Challenged
A minority partner may contend that a controlling partner deliberately issued an unnecessary capital call to dilute or financially pressure another owner.
Relevant evidence may include:
- Property budgets;
- Bank balances;
- Loan requirements;
- Operating statements;
- Repair estimates;
- Alternative financing;
- Prior capital calls;
- Internal communications; and
- Actual use of contributed funds.
The dispute may involve both contractual authority and fiduciary-duty allegations.
Partner Loans Should Be Distinguished From Capital Contributions
A partner may fund partnership expenses beyond the amount the partner was obligated to contribute.
Under California’s statutory default rules, qualifying advances beyond agreed capital contributions may be treated as loans to the partnership.
This can create disputes concerning:
- Whether the payment was equity or debt;
- Interest;
- Repayment priority;
- Approval of the advance;
- Whether other partners had a right to participate;
- Whether the loan was commercially reasonable; and
- Whether repayment was improperly prioritized over distributions.
Commercial property partnerships should document substantial partner advances when they occur rather than attempting to characterize them years later during litigation.
Profit Distribution Disputes Are Common
One partner may manage the property while another primarily contributes capital. Disagreements can arise over when available cash should be distributed.
Potential disputes may concern:
- Operating reserves;
- Debt reserves;
- Capital expenditures;
- Future construction;
- Tenant improvement reserves;
- Partner loans;
- Property management fees;
- Development fees;
- Preferred returns; and
- Distribution percentages.
The partnership agreement should identify whether management has discretion to retain cash and what limitations apply.
California’s Default Profit-Sharing Rule May Surprise Property Owners
If the partnership agreement does not provide otherwise, California Corporations Code Section 16401 generally entitles each partner to an equal share of partnership profits, with losses allocated in proportion to the partners’ shares of profits.
This default rule can produce unexpected results when partners contributed substantially different amounts but never documented a different economic arrangement.
For example, a partner who supplied more acquisition capital should not automatically assume that the larger contribution alone establishes a larger statutory profit share if no agreement provides for it.
Partnership Accounting Records Can Become Central Evidence
Commercial property partnerships typically generate substantial financial information.
Records may include:
- Rent collections;
- Operating expenses;
- Mortgage payments;
- Partner contributions;
- Partner distributions;
- Management fees;
- Construction expenses;
- Tenant deposits;
- Tax payments;
- Insurance payments;
- Refinancing proceeds;
- Capital improvements; and
- Sale proceeds.
Disputes become significantly more difficult when the partnership has not maintained separate and reliable financial records.
Partners Have Statutory Rights to Partnership Books and Records
California Corporations Code Section 16403 requires a partnership to provide partners and their agents and attorneys access to partnership books and records.
The right generally includes an opportunity to inspect and copy records during ordinary business hours.
Former partners also have access rights concerning records pertaining to periods during which they were partners.
A partner may seek information concerning:
- Bank accounts;
- Rent rolls;
- Leases;
- Loan statements;
- Tax returns;
- General ledgers;
- Invoices;
- Property management reports;
- Capital accounts;
- Distributions;
- Partner advances;
- Related-party transactions; and
- Property sale or refinancing documents.
Information Rights Extend Beyond Formal Accounting Books
Section 16403 also generally requires the partnership and partners to furnish information reasonably required for the proper exercise of a partner’s rights and duties.
On demand, additional information concerning partnership business and affairs generally must be furnished unless the request or information sought is unreasonable or otherwise improper under the circumstances.
This can be important when a managing partner technically provides annual financial statements but refuses to disclose documents needed to evaluate disputed transactions.
The Partnership Agreement Cannot Unreasonably Eliminate Record Access
California Corporations Code Section 16103 restricts partnership agreements from unreasonably limiting statutory rights to books, records, and partnership information.
A controlling partner therefore should not assume that broad management authority automatically permits complete financial secrecy.
Records disputes often precede larger claims involving misappropriation, improper distributions, self-dealing, or dissolution.
California Partners Owe Fiduciary Duties
California Corporations Code Section 16404 identifies statutory duties of loyalty and care owed by partners to the partnership and other partners.
The duty of loyalty includes obligations involving:
- Accounting for property, profits, or benefits derived from partnership business;
- Accounting for benefits derived from use of partnership property or information;
- Partnership opportunities;
- Avoiding specified adverse dealings with the partnership; and
- Refraining from competing with the partnership before dissolution.
The statutory duty of care generally requires a partner to refrain from grossly negligent or reckless conduct, intentional misconduct, or knowing violations of law.
Partners must also exercise rights and discharge duties consistently with the obligation of good faith and fair dealing.
Self-Dealing Transactions Can Create Fiduciary Claims
A managing partner may have interests in other companies that provide services to the property.
Related-party transactions may involve:
- Property management;
- Construction;
- Maintenance;
- Brokerage;
- Development services;
- Financing;
- Insurance;
- Consulting;
- Equipment rental; and
- Vendor contracts.
Affiliate transactions are not automatically prohibited, but they can generate litigation when another partner contends that the transaction was unauthorized, undisclosed, or structured primarily to benefit the controlling partner.
Secret Profits Can Be Subject to Accounting and Recovery
A partner may breach the duty of loyalty by receiving undisclosed benefits arising from partnership business or property.
Potential allegations may involve:
- Undisclosed commissions;
- Vendor rebates;
- Construction markups;
- Property management fees;
- Brokerage compensation;
- Acquisition opportunities;
- Refinancing fees;
- Tenant payments; or
- Other personal benefits.
A partner may seek an accounting and other legal or equitable remedies where partnership funds or opportunities were allegedly diverted.
Partnership Opportunity Disputes Can Arise in Real Estate
Partners may disagree about whether a new property acquisition should have been offered to the existing partnership.
For example, one partner may learn through partnership business that an adjacent parcel is available and then acquire it individually or through another entity.
A dispute may involve:
- The partnership’s stated business purpose;
- How the opportunity was discovered;
- Whether partnership information was used;
- Whether the partnership had the ability to acquire the property;
- Whether the opportunity was disclosed;
- Whether the partners rejected it; and
- Any contractual opportunity waiver.
Section 16404 expressly includes appropriation of a partnership opportunity within the statutory duty-of-loyalty framework.
Partners Are Not Prohibited From Protecting Their Own Interests
California law recognizes that a partner does not automatically violate a partnership duty merely because the partner’s conduct also furthers the partner’s own economic interest.
Commercial partners frequently disagree legitimately about:
- Whether to sell;
- Whether to refinance;
- Whether to contribute more money;
- Whether to renovate;
- How much cash to distribute;
- Whether to replace management; and
- Whether to continue holding the property.
A disagreement becomes a legal problem when conduct violates the partnership agreement, statutory duties, or another enforceable obligation—not merely because the partners favor different business strategies.
Deadlock Can Threaten the Property’s Value
A 50-50 partnership can become unable to operate if important decisions require agreement from both owners.
Deadlock may prevent the partnership from:
- Refinancing a maturing loan;
- Funding emergency repairs;
- Approving leases;
- Making capital calls;
- Replacing property management;
- Selling the property;
- Settling litigation;
- Approving development;
- Obtaining insurance; or
- Responding to lender requirements.
Delay itself can therefore become economically destructive even before either partner proves wrongdoing.
The Partnership Agreement May Contain a Deadlock Remedy
Partners should review the agreement before seeking judicial intervention.
Contractual deadlock mechanisms may include:
- Mediation;
- Arbitration;
- Buy-sell procedures;
- Appraisal;
- Put rights;
- Call rights;
- Rights of first offer;
- Forced marketing of the property;
- Third-party decision makers; or
- Dissolution triggers.
Following the agreed process can sometimes resolve the dispute without requiring liquidation of the underlying property.
A Partner Can Seek Legal or Equitable Relief Without Waiting for Dissolution
California Corporations Code Section 16405 permits a partnership to maintain an action against a partner for breach of the partnership agreement or violation of a duty causing harm to the partnership.
The statute also permits a partner to seek legal or equitable relief against the partnership or another partner to enforce partnership rights.
Potential remedies may involve:
- Breach of contract damages;
- Fiduciary-duty claims;
- Declaratory relief;
- Injunctive relief;
- Accounting;
- Enforcement of information rights;
- Dissociation-related rights;
- Buyout rights;
- Dissolution; and
- Other appropriate equitable remedies.
A partner does not necessarily have to wait until the entire partnership is dissolved to enforce existing rights.
An Accounting Can Be Important in Commercial Property Disputes
An accounting may become appropriate when partnership finances are too complex to resolve through a simple payment claim.
Accounting issues may involve:
- Capital accounts;
- Partner contributions;
- Rent receipts;
- Management expenses;
- Partner reimbursements;
- Loans;
- Distributions;
- Construction costs;
- Refinancing proceeds;
- Affiliate payments;
- Tax obligations;
- Sale proceeds; and
- Other partnership transactions.
Section 16405 expressly recognizes that a partner may pursue statutory rights with or without an accounting as to partnership business, depending on the claim.
Temporary Injunctive Relief May Be Necessary
Some partnership disputes involve threatened transactions that cannot easily be reversed after they occur.
A partner may seek temporary or preliminary relief in appropriate circumstances when another partner allegedly intends to:
- Sell partnership property without authority;
- Record unauthorized financing;
- Transfer partnership funds;
- Enter a major lease;
- Destroy records;
- Divert rents;
- Remove substantial cash from partnership accounts; or
- Take another action threatening irreparable harm.
The party seeking an injunction must satisfy the legal requirements applicable to extraordinary equitable relief.
A Receiver May Be Considered in Severe Property Management Disputes
When a partnership conflict threatens the commercial property’s operation or preservation, a party may seek appointment of a receiver if legally justified.
Depending on the court’s order, a receiver may potentially:
- Collect rent;
- Pay operating expenses;
- Maintain insurance;
- Manage tenants;
- Preserve the property;
- Pay taxes;
- Maintain accounting records;
- Address urgent repairs; and
- Report to the court.
Receivership is a significant remedy and is not automatic merely because partners strongly disagree.
Judicial Expulsion of a Partner May Be Available
California Corporations Code Section 16601 permits judicial expulsion of a partner in specified circumstances.
On application by the partnership or another partner, judicial dissociation may be available where a partner:
- Engaged in wrongful conduct materially and adversely affecting the partnership business;
- Willfully or persistently committed a material breach of the partnership agreement or applicable partnership duties; or
- Engaged in conduct relating to partnership business making it not reasonably practicable to continue the business with that partner.
This remedy can be relevant when the business remains viable but the relationship with one partner has become untenable.
Expulsion Should Be Distinguished From Dissolution
Removing one partner does not necessarily require terminating the partnership itself.
If the partnership owns valuable income-producing real estate, the remaining owners may prefer to continue operating the property while separating from the partner whose conduct caused the dispute.
Whether that result is available depends on:
- The partnership agreement;
- The statutory basis for dissociation;
- Financing restrictions;
- Buyout obligations;
- Tax consequences; and
- The facts supporting removal.
A Partner Can Voluntarily Dissociate
California Corporations Code Section 16601 recognizes dissociation when the partnership receives notice of a partner’s express will to withdraw, among other triggering events.
Section 16602 further provides that a partner has the power to dissociate at any time, rightfully or wrongfully.
The distinction matters because a withdrawal that violates the partnership agreement or occurs improperly in a partnership for a definite term or particular undertaking may constitute wrongful dissociation.
Wrongful Dissociation Can Lead to Damages
A partner who wrongfully dissociates may be liable to the partnership and other partners for damages caused by that dissociation.
Commercial property damages could potentially involve losses arising from:
- Disrupted financing;
- Failed guaranty arrangements;
- Loss of management services;
- Transaction delays;
- Forced replacement costs;
- Property sale disruption; or
- Other consequences caused by the wrongful withdrawal.
The partnership must still establish causation and legally recoverable damages rather than simply labeling the departure wrongful.
Dissociation Can Trigger a Statutory Buyout
California Corporations Code Section 16701 generally requires a partnership to purchase a dissociated partner’s interest, subject to statutory provisions and any applicable agreement.
Under the statutory valuation framework, the buyout price generally reflects the amount that would have been distributable to the departing partner if, on the date of dissociation, partnership assets had been sold for the greater of their liquidation value or the value based on sale of the entire business as a going concern without the dissociated partner.
Interest generally accrues from the date of dissociation to payment.
Real Estate Valuation Can Make a Partner Buyout Highly Contested
When the partnership’s principal asset is commercial property, valuation may become the most significant issue in the case.
The parties may disagree about:
- Property fair market value;
- Capitalization rates;
- Net operating income;
- Vacancy;
- Deferred maintenance;
- Development potential;
- Existing debt;
- Prepayment costs;
- Environmental liabilities;
- Pending capital expenditures;
- Lease value;
- Construction obligations; and
- Other partnership liabilities.
Qualified real estate appraisers, accountants, and other valuation experts may be necessary.
The Statutory Buyout Calculation Is Not Necessarily a Simple Percentage of Appraised Property Value
A departing partner may believe that a 40 percent partnership interest automatically equals 40 percent of the gross real estate value.
The calculation can be more complicated.
Partnership liabilities, partner accounts, property debt, offsets, other assets, and applicable statutory valuation rules can affect the final amount.
A complete buyout analysis should therefore consider the partnership’s entire financial position rather than only the property’s appraisal.
Written Buyout Demands Trigger Important Procedures
Section 16701 contains procedures governing buyout disputes after dissociation.
If no buyout agreement is reached within 120 days after a written demand for payment, the partnership generally must pay the amount it estimates to be the buyout price and accrued interest, subject to permitted offsets and applicable statutory rules.
The statutory procedure also requires supporting information concerning the partnership and calculation of the proposed payment.
Parties should follow the statutory requirements carefully rather than allowing an informal valuation disagreement to remain unresolved indefinitely.
Buyout Litigation Has Its Own Filing Deadlines
Section 16701 permits a dissociated partner to bring an action to determine the buyout price, offsets, and other applicable terms.
The statute contains specific timing requirements tied to the partnership’s tender of payment or offer to pay and to the dissociated partner’s written demand.
Because those periods can affect the right to challenge the buyout, a departing partner should not assume that general commercial litigation deadlines are the only deadlines that apply.
Wrongful Dissociation Damages Can Be Offset Against the Buyout
If the departing partner wrongfully dissociated or owes other amounts to the partnership, Section 16701 permits qualifying amounts to be offset against the statutory buyout price.
Potential offsets may involve:
- Damages from wrongful dissociation;
- Unpaid partner obligations;
- Improper distributions;
- Amounts misappropriated from the partnership;
- Outstanding partner loans owed to the partnership; or
- Other qualifying amounts.
The dissociated partner may dispute whether the offset exists or whether the partnership exaggerated the amount to reduce the buyout.
Judicial Dissolution May Be Available When the Partnership Cannot Continue
California Corporations Code Section 16801 establishes circumstances under which a partnership may be dissolved and wound up.
On application by a partner, judicial dissolution may be available where:
- The economic purpose of the partnership is likely to be unreasonably frustrated;
- Another partner has engaged in conduct making it not reasonably practicable to carry on business with that partner; or
- It is otherwise not reasonably practicable to conduct the partnership business in conformity with the partnership agreement.
The statute also provides other dissolution events depending on whether the partnership is at will, is for a definite term, or was formed for a particular undertaking.
Not Every Partnership Disagreement Justifies Dissolution
Dissolution is a significant remedy, particularly where the partnership owns valuable commercial real estate.
A disagreement over one lease, one distribution, or one management decision may not necessarily establish that continuing the partnership is no longer reasonably practicable.
Courts may consider the broader circumstances, including:
- The seriousness of the deadlock;
- Whether the business remains functional;
- Repeated misconduct;
- Whether contractual remedies exist;
- The partnership’s purpose;
- Whether essential decisions can still be made; and
- Whether the partners can realistically continue operating together.
Dissolution Does Not Immediately End the Partnership’s Business
Once dissolution occurs, partnership affairs generally must be wound up.
California Corporations Code Section 16803 allows the person conducting the winding up to take necessary actions that may include:
- Preserving the business or property for a reasonable period;
- Prosecuting and defending litigation;
- Settling partnership business;
- Disposing of partnership property;
- Discharging liabilities;
- Distributing remaining assets;
- Mediating or arbitrating disputes; and
- Performing other necessary winding-up acts.
For commercial property, winding up may require continued rent collection, insurance, maintenance, debt service, and tenant administration before the asset can be sold or otherwise resolved.
The Court Can Supervise Winding Up for Good Cause
Section 16803 permits judicial supervision of winding up upon application by specified interested parties and a showing of good cause.
Judicial supervision may become relevant when partners cannot agree about:
- Property marketing;
- Sale price;
- Broker selection;
- Payment of creditors;
- Property repairs;
- Lease renewals;
- Distribution of sale proceeds; or
- Management during the winding-up period.
Creditors Are Paid Before Partners Receive the Remaining Surplus
California Corporations Code Section 16807 establishes the general winding-up framework for partnership accounts.
Partnership assets are applied to discharge partnership obligations to creditors before surplus is distributed to the partners.
Depending on the circumstances, creditors may include:
- Mortgage lenders;
- Trade creditors;
- Contractors;
- Tax authorities;
- Vendors;
- Employees;
- Tenants with valid claims;
- Partners who are legitimate partnership creditors; and
- Other parties holding partnership obligations.
Partners generally receive only the net amount remaining after partnership obligations and accounts are resolved.
Each Partner Is Entitled to Settlement of Partnership Accounts Upon Winding Up
Section 16807 also provides for settlement of partnership accounts during winding up.
Profits and losses resulting from liquidation are credited or charged to the partners’ accounts, and the remaining amounts are distributed according to applicable partnership rights.
Accounting disputes may involve:
- Historical capital contributions;
- Prior distributions;
- Partner loans;
- Improper withdrawals;
- Unpaid expenses;
- Sale costs;
- Property debt;
- Tax obligations;
- Closing adjustments; and
- Other partnership liabilities.
General Partners Can Face Personal Exposure for Partnership Obligations
Under California Corporations Code Section 16306, general partners are generally jointly and severally liable for partnership obligations, subject to statutory exceptions and other applicable law.
This exposure can be important when a real estate partnership faces liabilities exceeding the value of the property.
Potential partnership obligations may include:
- Commercial loans;
- Lease obligations;
- Construction debts;
- Vendor claims;
- Judgments;
- Environmental liabilities;
- Property-related tort claims; and
- Other contractual obligations.
Entity structure, guaranties, insurance, and specific statutory protections should be reviewed when evaluating personal exposure.
A Judgment Against the Partnership Is Not Automatically a Judgment Against Every Partner
California Corporations Code Section 16307 distinguishes between liability of the partnership and enforcement of a judgment against an individual partner.
A judgment entered solely against the partnership is not by itself a judgment against a partner.
If a claimant seeks to recover from a partner personally, applicable procedural and substantive requirements must still be satisfied.
This distinction can become important in litigation involving partnership-owned commercial property.
Loan Guaranties Can Create Separate Personal Liability
Even where entity law would otherwise affect a partner’s exposure, a partner may separately agree to guarantee partnership debt.
Commercial real estate financing may include:
- Repayment guaranties;
- Completion guaranties;
- Environmental indemnities;
- Nonrecourse carveout guaranties;
- Interest guaranties;
- Carry guaranties; and
- Other negotiated credit support.
The guaranty creates rights and obligations separate from the partner’s ordinary ownership interest.
Partnership Disputes Can Trigger Loan Defaults
A serious ownership dispute can threaten the property’s financing even when mortgage payments remain current.
Loan documents may restrict:
- Changes in control;
- Partner transfers;
- Dissolution;
- Management changes;
- Unauthorized distributions;
- Additional borrowing;
- Property transfers;
- Litigation affecting the property; and
- Changes to guarantors.
A partner seeking dissolution, withdrawal, or a forced buyout should therefore review the loan documents before assuming the internal ownership remedy has no effect on the lender.
Lender Consent May Be Necessary for a Buyout or Ownership Change
A negotiated partnership settlement may contemplate one partner purchasing another’s interest.
The parties should determine whether the transaction:
- Triggers a change-of-control provision;
- Requires lender consent;
- Changes guarantors;
- Creates a prohibited transfer;
- Requires refinancing;
- Impacts net worth covenants; or
- Changes property management.
A settlement that violates the mortgage documents can exchange one dispute for a new loan default.
Partnership Disputes Can Affect Commercial Tenants
Tenants generally expect the ownership entity to continue performing lease obligations regardless of internal disagreements among its partners.
A partnership conflict may nevertheless affect:
- Repair decisions;
- Tenant improvements;
- Lease renewals;
- Security deposits;
- Property management;
- Common area maintenance;
- Construction;
- Tenant concessions; and
- Landlord consent requests.
Owners should attempt to preserve ordinary property operations while their internal dispute proceeds.
Partner Misappropriation Can Support Significant Claims
A particularly serious dispute may arise when one partner is accused of diverting partnership funds or property.
Potential allegations may involve:
- Diverted rents;
- Unauthorized distributions;
- Payments to personal accounts;
- False expenses;
- Improper affiliate payments;
- Personal use of partnership property;
- Unreported tenant payments;
- Unauthorized loan proceeds; or
- Diversion of sale or refinancing proceeds.
Bank statements, accounting systems, property management records, invoices, and electronic communications may become critical evidence.
Forensic Accounting May Be Necessary
When financial records span many years or contain complex related-party transactions, ordinary accounting summaries may be insufficient.
A forensic accountant may assist in tracing:
- Partner contributions;
- Distributions;
- Rent income;
- Management fees;
- Partner loans;
- Related-party payments;
- Property expenses;
- Refinancing proceeds;
- Construction payments;
- Tax payments;
- Sale proceeds; and
- Transfers among affiliated entities.
Property Management Fees Can Generate Conflicts
A managing partner may also own the company managing the partnership’s property.
Disputes may concern:
- Whether the fee was authorized;
- Whether the amount was commercially reasonable;
- Whether the relationship was disclosed;
- Whether additional fees were added without approval;
- Whether the manager performed the required services; and
- Whether property expenses were improperly marked up.
The partnership agreement and management contract should be reviewed together.
Development and Construction Projects Can Intensify Partnership Conflicts
A partnership formed around commercial redevelopment may experience disputes when project costs increase substantially.
Partners may disagree over:
- Construction budgets;
- Change orders;
- Contractor selection;
- Development fees;
- Additional capital;
- Financing;
- Schedule delays;
- Value engineering;
- Design changes; and
- Whether the project should continue.
The managing partner may argue that additional spending is necessary to protect the investment, while another partner may contend that management has exceeded its authority.
Property Sale Disputes Can Be Economically Significant
Commercial partners frequently disagree about the appropriate time to sell.
One owner may favor an immediate sale because market conditions are favorable. Another may prefer to hold the property for appreciation or future redevelopment.
The agreement may address:
- Mandatory holding periods;
- Minimum sale prices;
- Approval thresholds;
- Appraisal requirements;
- Broker selection;
- Rights of first offer;
- Buy-sell procedures;
- Marketing periods; and
- Distribution of proceeds.
An Unauthorized Sale Can Create Multiple Layers of Litigation
If one partner attempts to sell the partnership’s property without proper authority, disputes may involve:
- The partner’s actual authority;
- Apparent authority;
- The purchaser’s knowledge;
- The partnership agreement;
- Recorded statements of authority;
- Title insurance;
- Escrow;
- Fiduciary duties; and
- Potential injunctive relief.
Prompt action may be important if closing has not yet occurred.
Tax Consequences Can Affect the Choice of Remedy
A forced property sale, partner buyout, distribution, refinancing, or dissolution can produce materially different tax consequences.
Potential considerations may involve:
- Capital gain;
- Depreciation recapture;
- Debt allocation;
- Partner basis;
- Capital accounts;
- Transfer taxes;
- Property tax reassessment issues;
- Like-kind exchange planning; and
- Allocation of liabilities.
Legal strategy should therefore be coordinated with appropriate tax professionals before implementing a settlement or dissolution.
Bankruptcy of a Partner Can Complicate the Dispute
A partner’s financial distress may affect partnership rights without necessarily transferring management rights to a creditor.
Potential issues can include:
- Dissociation;
- Transferable economic interests;
- Charging orders;
- Buyout rights;
- Loan covenants;
- Guaranties;
- Automatic stay issues; and
- Bankruptcy estate rights.
Bankruptcy issues should be evaluated under applicable federal law together with California partnership law.
Partner Creditors Generally Reach Economic Interests Differently From Partnership Property
Because partnership property belongs to the partnership rather than individual partners, a creditor of one partner ordinarily should not assume that it can directly seize a partnership-owned commercial building as though the partner individually owned that property.
The creditor’s rights may instead focus on the partner’s transferable partnership interest and remedies available under applicable charging-order and other laws.
This distinction can become important when one partner’s personal financial problems threaten an otherwise healthy real estate investment.
Settlement Can Preserve More Value Than Dissolution
Commercial real estate can lose substantial value when ownership litigation prevents ordinary decisions for an extended period.
A negotiated resolution may include:
- Purchase of one partner’s interest;
- Sale of the property;
- Refinancing followed by a distribution;
- Division of multiple assets;
- Removal of a managing partner;
- Revised management rights;
- Appointment of an independent property manager;
- Modified distribution provisions;
- Resolution of partner loans;
- Release of disputed claims; or
- A structured exit over time.
The settlement should account for lender requirements, taxes, leases, guaranties, and ongoing property obligations.
A Buyout Agreement Should Address More Than Price
A negotiated partner buyout may need to address:
- Purchase price;
- Valuation date;
- Payment timing;
- Security for deferred payments;
- Accrued distributions;
- Partner loans;
- Tax allocations;
- Release from guaranties;
- Lender consent;
- Indemnity;
- Books and records;
- Pending litigation;
- Confidentiality;
- Mutual releases; and
- Future cooperation.
A departing partner should not assume that selling the partnership interest automatically releases personal guaranties previously provided to lenders or other creditors.
Document Preservation Is Critical
Commercial property partnerships may operate for decades, making historical records especially important.
Relevant evidence can include:
- The partnership agreement;
- Amendments;
- Property deeds;
- Loan documents;
- Guaranties;
- Tax returns;
- Bank statements;
- Capital account records;
- Property management agreements;
- Leases;
- Rent rolls;
- Financial statements;
- Distribution records;
- Capital call notices;
- Construction contracts;
- Appraisals;
- Meeting minutes;
- Emails;
- Text messages; and
- Documents concerning disputed transactions.
Electronic accounting and property management data should also be preserved when litigation becomes reasonably foreseeable.
A Detailed Chronology Can Clarify the Partnership Dispute
Many partnership cases involve years of business decisions that appear different when viewed in isolation.
A useful chronology may identify:
- Formation of the partnership;
- Initial capital contributions;
- Property acquisition;
- Financing;
- Major leases;
- Capital calls;
- Partner advances;
- Distributions;
- Refinancing;
- Construction projects;
- Affiliate transactions;
- Disputed management decisions;
- Requests for records;
- Withdrawal notices;
- Buyout demands; and
- Events leading to litigation.
The chronology can help distinguish an isolated disagreement from a pattern of conduct supporting broader legal remedies.
Partners Should Evaluate the Property’s Economics Before Litigation Escalates
A legally strong claim does not eliminate the practical costs of prolonged ownership conflict.
The parties should understand:
- Current property value;
- Outstanding debt;
- Loan maturity;
- Current net operating income;
- Vacancy;
- Required repairs;
- Upcoming tenant expirations;
- Capital requirements;
- Potential refinancing;
- Sale costs;
- Tax effects; and
- Likely buyout value.
Those figures can help determine whether the most rational outcome is continued ownership, a partner buyout, or sale of the property.
Careful Partnership Agreements Can Reduce Future Litigation
Commercial property owners can reduce uncertainty by addressing foreseeable disputes when the partnership is formed.
A detailed partnership agreement may address:
- Management authority;
- Major decisions;
- Voting thresholds;
- Capital calls;
- Failure-to-fund remedies;
- Partner loans;
- Affiliate transactions;
- Fees;
- Distributions;
- Books and records;
- Property sales;
- Refinancing;
- Guaranties;
- Transfer restrictions;
- Deadlock;
- Withdrawal;
- Buyout valuation;
- Death or disability;
- Dissolution;
- Dispute resolution; and
- Attorney’s fees.
Clear rules are particularly valuable when the partnership owns one major commercial property and the partners cannot simply divide the underlying asset without affecting its value.
Did You Know?
Under California partnership law, a partner generally is not a co-owner of property owned by the partnership. The partner’s transferable interest ordinarily consists of the partner’s economic rights to profits, losses, and distributions, which means a dispute over partnership-owned commercial real estate can require partnership remedies rather than a direct partition of the property.
Protecting Ownership Interests in Commercial Property Partnership Disputes
Commercial property partnership disputes can involve management control, capital calls, distributions, fiduciary duties, books and records, unauthorized transactions, financing, partner withdrawal, valuation, buyouts, and dissolution. Because the real estate may remain occupied, financed, and operational while the owners litigate, an effective strategy should protect both the partner’s legal rights and the value of the underlying property. Careful review of the partnership agreement, financial records, title documents, financing arrangements, and California partnership statutes is essential before selecting a remedy.
Putterman Law represents commercial property owners, investors, partners, developers, and other businesses in disputes involving partnerships, fiduciary duties, ownership interests, business contracts, real estate investments, buyouts, dissolution, and related commercial litigation.
Learn more about commercial litigation services at Putterman Law
FAQs
What are common causes of commercial property partnership disputes?
Common disputes involve management authority, capital calls, distributions, refinancing, property sales, partner loans, related-party transactions, access to financial records, alleged misuse of partnership funds, fiduciary duties, partner withdrawal, valuation, and disagreements over whether the partnership should continue.
Does each partner directly own a percentage of partnership real estate?
Generally, no. Under California partnership law, property acquired by the partnership belongs to the partnership rather than to the partners individually. A partner’s transferable interest generally consists of economic rights involving partnership profits, losses, and distributions.
Can a partner force partition of commercial property owned by the partnership?
Not necessarily. Because a partner is not generally a direct co-owner of partnership property, ordinary partition rights applicable to direct real estate co-owners may not apply in the same way. Partnership remedies such as buyout, dissociation, dissolution, or winding up may be more appropriate. A different analysis applies when the individuals directly own the property as tenants in common.
Can a California partner obtain partnership financial records?
Yes. California Corporations Code Section 16403 generally gives partners access to partnership books and records and requires specified partnership information to be provided. Partnership agreements generally cannot unreasonably restrict those statutory access and information rights.
What fiduciary duties do California partners owe?
California Corporations Code Section 16404 identifies duties of loyalty and care and requires partners to exercise rights and discharge partnership duties consistently with good faith and fair dealing. The duty of loyalty includes obligations concerning partnership profits, property, opportunities, adverse dealings, and competition.
Can a partner be removed for misconduct?
Potentially. California Corporations Code Section 16601 permits judicial expulsion in specified circumstances, including qualifying wrongful conduct materially affecting partnership business, persistent material breaches of the partnership agreement or applicable duties, or conduct making it not reasonably practicable to continue business with that partner.
Can a partner simply withdraw from a commercial real estate partnership?
A partner generally has the power to dissociate by expressing an intent to withdraw, but the dissociation may be wrongful if it violates the partnership agreement or certain statutory rules applicable to partnerships for a definite term or particular undertaking. Wrongful dissociation can create liability for resulting damages.
What happens to a partner’s interest after dissociation?
California Corporations Code Section 16701 generally provides for purchase of a dissociated partner’s interest. The statutory buyout calculation generally considers what the partner would have received if partnership assets were valued and the partnership wound up as of the dissociation date under the statutory formula, subject to offsets and other applicable requirements.
When can a partner seek judicial dissolution?
California Corporations Code Section 16801 permits judicial dissolution in qualifying circumstances, including when the partnership’s economic purpose is likely to be unreasonably frustrated, another partner’s conduct makes continued partnership business not reasonably practicable, or it is otherwise not reasonably practicable to carry on the business in conformity with the partnership agreement.
What happens to commercial property when a partnership is dissolved?
Dissolution generally leads to winding up of partnership affairs. Partnership property may be preserved temporarily, sold or otherwise disposed of as appropriate, partnership liabilities are addressed, and remaining surplus is distributed according to the partners’ rights after partnership accounts are settled.


